Non-Toxic Pet Toys
Most pet toys are basically a chemical cocktail dressed up like fun. Plastics, dyes, and who-knows-what-else end up in your dog or cat’s mouth—sometimes causing vomiting, rashes, or worse. Because apparently “safe for pets” is just a suggestion these days. We’ve hunted down the non-toxic pet toys that are actually meant for play—no microplastic "snow" or sketchy toxins included. I’ve done the digging to find plastic-free dog toys and safe cat toys that are durable, chewable, and (shockingly) safe—so your furbaby can entertain themselves without you watching them like a CSI episode of “What Are They Eating Now?”
West Paw Hurley Dog Toy
The Marathon Bone
Made from zero-waste Zogoflex material that is 100% recyclable and non-toxic.
A durable, solid bone design that won't splinter or crumble like "real" bones.
It bounces and floats, making it way more versatile than a standard heavy chew.
Non-Toxic Chew Toys: for when they just need to gnaw on something that isn't your baseboards.
Goughnuts Ring Dog Toy
The Safety First Circle
Engineered from natural, non-toxic rubber designed by actual polymer chemists.
Features a "safety indicator" inner core that turns red when it’s time to replace it.
The specialized shape and density make it nearly impossible for power-chewers to destroy.
Brady the Rope Tug Toy
The Pesticide-Free Pull
Made from 100% organic cotton so they aren't actually flossing with bleached synthetics.
Dyed with safe, non-toxic colors that won't leak heavy metals into their mouth.
Built with a heavy-duty weave that actually survives the "shredder" phase.
West Paw Zogoflex Tux
The Kibble Vault
Built from ultra-tough, BPA-free Zogoflex for the most aggressive "land sharks."
A genius way to hide treats or freeze peanut butter for some toxic-free brain work.
It floats and is dishwasher safe, because nobody has time for gross, slimy toys.
Non-Toxic Interactive Toys: Brain games to keep them busy (and save your sanity).
KONG Classic Dog Toy
The Boredom Buster
Crafted from all-natural, non-toxic rubber that has been the gold standard for over 40 years.
Perfect for stuffing with healthy treats or peanut butter to provide hours of mental stimulation.
The erratic bounce makes for a wild game of fetch that burns off that "zoomie" energy fast.
Plastic-Free Plush & Soft Toys: No synthetic fluff, no microplastic "snow".
Made from 100% recycled plastic water bottles, including the fabric, stuffing, and even the thread.
Each toy redirects about 6 to 9 plastic bottles from landfills and oceans—so it's a win for the planet.
It features a built-in squeaker and it actually floats, making it a rare plush that's pool-ready.
Spunky Pup Clean Earth Llama
The Recycled Party Animal
Organic Cotton Dog Toys
The Farmers Market Haul
Handmade from 100% GOTS-certified organic cotton with a textured knit that helps gently scrub teeth.
Completely free from synthetic stuffing, toxic dyes, and lead—basically, it's as clean as it gets.
Includes a carrot, pineapple, and pear, all designed with a built-in squeaker to keep them engaged.
Creature ECO Wool Ring
The Slobber-Proof Circle
Made from 100% organic wool—zero plastic fibers, toxic glues, or nasty chemical dyes.
Naturally odor-resistant and antimicrobial, keeping the "funk" away longer than cotton.
Fully compostable at the end of its life, making it a true zero-waste swap for your home.
Non-Toxic Balls & Chasers: High-velocity fun, minus the toxic aftertaste.
Made from BPA-free Zogoflex, so it’s way safer for constant mouth contact than standard plastic balls.
Features a unique "un-round" shape that creates a crazy, unpredictable bounce to keep them guessing.
It fits in standard ball launchers and floats, making it the only fetch ball you’ll actually need.
West Paw Zogoflex Jive Ball
The Tennis Ball Killer
Creature Eco Wool Dog Balls
The Planet-Friendly Pitch
Made from 100% organic New Zealand wool—no hidden plastic cores or toxic chemical glues.
Naturally antimicrobial and odor-resistant, plus they're fully machine washable and dryable.
The dense, felted wool provides a satisfying "squish" that's way gentler on teeth and jaws than hard rubber.
West Paw Seaflex Drifty
The Ocean-Saver Bone
Crafted from Seaflex, a non-toxic blend of recycled ocean plastic and Zogoflex.
Shaped like a real bone but designed with a "bulbous" end for a more erratic, fun bounce.
100% dishwasher safe and BPA-free, making it way cleaner than a literal piece of driftwood.
Organic Cat Toys: Because your cat’s "zoomies" shouldn't be chemically induced.
Crafted from 100% natural hemp fabric—no synthetic fibers or microplastic shedding.
Stuffed with organic catnip, silvervine, and buckwheat hulls for a totally non-toxic "crinkle" experience.
Hemp is naturally mold-resistant and odor-repellent, so it stays fresh even after some serious kitty slobber.
Tia the Hemp Turtle
The Plastic-Free Party Turtle
Yeowww! Organic Catnip Banana
The Organic Heavy Hitter
Stuffed with 100% certified organic catnip—absolutely zero polyester "fluff" or chemical fillers.
Made with durable 100% cotton canvas and non-toxic dyes, making it safe for aggressive lickers.
Hand-sewn and designed to be the perfect shape for cats to grab, hug, and kick.
🍍 Heads up: Clean AF Life is always a work in progress — we’re constantly adding more non-toxic goodies to our shop. Keep checking back for fresh finds and new favorites!
Shop Disclosure: This page features my hand-picked recommendations for a Clean AF home. If you purchase through the links below, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. These commissions help me keep the lights on and the research going—your support is endlessly appreciated! 💚